Part 1: Why I Don't Do Clean Slates
I went to architecture school, which qualifies me to have opinions about buildings and, by the loose standards of the internet, everything else. The one thing that survived the debt, the all-nighters, and the foam board was a method. The method is iterative design, and it has quietly ruined my ability to take utopian blueprints seriously.
Iterative design is simple to state and humiliating to practice. You build a crude version of the thing, test it against reality, find out where it fails, fix the failures, and test again. The first version is a prototype and is expected to be bad. Nobody in studio gets a gold star for a perfect first draft, because nobody has ever produced one. The final design is whatever remains after a long series of small embarrassments. A professor pins up your model, a dozen strangers explain why the stairs go nowhere, and you go home and fix the stairs. Do this enough times and you stop treating your own ideas as sacred. That is the whole point. The method is a machine for converting ego into information.
The lesson underneath is that the world is a better designer than you are, and the only way to access its intelligence is to let it hit your work. Feedback beats foresight. A mediocre idea that has survived fifty rounds of contact with reality will outperform a brilliant idea that has survived none.
This gives me a bias, and I'll state it plainly so you can discount for it. I prefer improving existing systems to burning them down and starting over. An existing institution is a prototype that has already been through many rounds of testing. It is ugly, full of patches and vestigial organs, and it still works well enough to be standing, which is more than can be said for most blueprints. Every strange rule in an old system is usually a scar from some failure you have not yet had the pleasure of repeating. A clean-slate rebuild throws all of that away. You keep the ambition and lose the data, then act surprised when the new thing rediscovers the old problems at a higher price.
There is a statistical version of this argument. Revolutions reset the clock to the first big solution, and every big solution drags a tail of side effects that take decades to find and fix. The old system had already paid that tuition. Improving it means working with a design whose worst failure modes have been found, instead of one whose failure modes are still in the mail. Tinkering is slow, unglamorous, and hard to put on a flag. It also tends to work, which in my experience is the property that matters.
Which raises an obvious question about what I'm doing for the rest of this post. I have never designed a government from nothing. Everything I've written so far borrows from existing ideas and precedents, and I use them as the raw material for improvements. Today I'm breaking my own rule on purpose. Think of it as the studio exercise where the professor says to ignore the site and draw the dream building, except the dream building is a country with a population of about a hundred thousand and a really good filing system. Treat it as a prototype. It will be wrong in ways I can't see yet, and the useful part is the part where you tell me where the stairs go.
Part 2: Design for a New City-State
The rules for this exercise are that there are no rules. Nobody gets to say "but that's how the old system does it." We are going to use modern methods, which mostly means asking what the actual problem is before reaching for a solution, a step that political design skips with remarkable consistency.
So here is my conception of the basic problem of government, and I haven't seen it written down this way before. There are lunatics, grifters, and chuds. Government is the activity of keeping the first two out of the building and getting the third into a condition where they can be trusted with it. Everything else is detail.
The chud
The chud is the well-meaning citizen who shows up at the city council meeting with a simple fix. Build more parking. Ban the thing. Lower the speed limit and the crashes will stop. He is sincere, he is usually kind to animals, and he is dangerous, because he believes the problem is simple.
It isn't simple because of what I call the problem-solutions cycle. Every problem demands a solution, and every solution creates new problems of varying size. Agriculture solved hunger and gave us feudalism, slavery, and a vast new menu of plagues. Air conditioning solved the heat and rearranged where people live. Cars, smartphones, and the pill all follow the same pattern. Reality behaves like turbulent fluid: push on it in one place and eddies form somewhere you weren't looking. Most of what a government actually does all day is clean up after previous governments.
The chud sees step one of the cycle and thinks it is the whole cycle. Put a stop sign on the corner, and traffic reroutes through the next street, and now that street wants a stop sign too. Cap the rent and you get fewer apartments. Abate the taxes and you get a warehouse. The libertarian answer, which is to do nothing, misreads the situation as badly as the chud does, because doing nothing is also a move in the cycle. The competent answer is to pick solutions whose side effects are smaller than the problems they fix, and to make sure each successive round of side effects is smaller than the last, until the turbulence smooths out into something closer to laminar flow. That takes information about how the last hundred cities fared, and the chud has not read about the last hundred cities. The chud is well-meaning, uninformed, and, to be blunt, a little stupid in the way all of us are outside our specialties. He is also the raw material for a good civil servant, which is why he gets a seat later in this design.
The lunatic
The lunatic is a different animal. The lunatic has what I'd call a fundamentally gnostic worldview: the real world is a corrupt arrangement, morality is the higher truth, and moral truth is entitled to overrule physical truth whenever the two disagree. This leads straight to the ought-therefore-is fallacy. Hume's old point was that you can't derive an ought from an is. The lunatic runs it in reverse and derives an is from an ought. Degrowth ought to win elections, therefore it does. The policy ought to work, therefore it works. When the facts object, the facts are accused of bigotry. I wrote about this in more detail in Principles Don't Care About Your Facts, and the short version is that wishing doesn't make it so, though it does make a very satisfying hobby.
The archetype has a name, and it is the reason this blog has the name it does. Mencius Moldbug, in his Gentle Introduction to Unqualified Reservations, calls it the Puritan and describes "the distinctive whining scream of the Puritan, speaking power to truth" in his usual fashion. Notice the inversion. The heroic version of this posture is speaking truth to power. The Puritan has the power, or is working hard to acquire it, and still presents himself as the persecuted prophet. In Moldbug's telling, the Puritan is not defined by any particular belief. It is a temperament: moral certainty combined with a shrill, accusatory tone, in which opponents are never merely mistaken but are liars, frauds, and heretics. He traces it from the Massachusetts Bay colony through the American Revolution to modern moralists, and points out that if you swap Scripture for Science and ministers for scientists, you get the same arrangement of experts interpreting truth and the state following along. The type is recognizable in any century, which is the sharpest observation in the piece. You do not need to read his whole body of work to find the temperament useful, and you can reject plenty of his politics and still see that the personality is real. It is the person who cannot lose an argument because he has defined disagreement as sin.
This blog is called The Anti-Puritan because it is the anti-lunatic. It opposes a psychology, not a party, and the psychology shows up on every side of every spectrum.
The grifter
The grifter is the lobbyist. The quintessential grifter rolls into a small town and demands a tax abatement to bring in a Walmart, which will then politely strangle the main street the town was trying to save. Grifters are slimy lobbyists who gather around politics the way flies gather on, well, what flies gather on. They are not confused about the problem like the chud, or deluded like the lunatic. They know exactly what they're doing, and what they're doing is converting public authority into private income.
The job
So the most fundamental job of government is sorting. Keep the grifters and lunatics out. Bring the chuds in, educate them extensively, and teach them to govern without being foolish. A confident state is therefore a massive process of personality selection, whose output is emotionally stable, high-IQ, competent, thoroughly educated civil servants. You give them real responsibility, then you watch their behavior closely for signs of madness or corruption, and you filter at every stage, forever. The process of designing a city-state's constitution therefore begins and centers on its personnel pipeline. The rest is plumbing.
Don't call us, we'll call you
No one who wants power is allowed to have it. Seeking power is treated as prima facie evidence that you are unqualified to hold it, and this is a rule, not a slogan. The government maintains a list of activists and lobbyists for the specific purpose of barring them from the civil service. Anyone who seeks power gets their name entered in a database and is excluded permanently. This isn't a secret. The public is told, loudly and repeatedly, that seeking power will disqualify you from it, because we want them to know. The rule works as a signal and as a filter at the same time: the people who respond to it by shutting up and doing their jobs are the ones we were looking for anyway.
It is not an oppressive society. You can write letters, make suggestions, and complain at length, and good feedback is genuinely valuable. What you cannot do is campaign for the job. Don't call us, we'll call you.
That means the state has to do the calling, and the first function of the government is to know who the stable, well-educated fraction of the population is. So it keeps the population under surveillance, and the purpose is recruitment. This is surveillance as a talent scout. You get noticed by not trying to get noticed.
The audition
Once you're noticed, you get a summons and are brought into a government office to audition. You're asked how you would handle a series of problems, and you answer in writing, in short essays. The essays are graded by someone who never meets you and so has no reason to like or dislike you, quite possibly an AI that compares your answer to the ideal one. The ideal answer comes from the national ideology. The state keeps a public-facing ideology, in the way the Chinese do, and the exam is that ideology condensed into short-answer questions. The ideology is public. The questions are a matter of state security and change frequently, so you can study the philosophy and still can't cram for the test.
The reason for all this is cost. It makes no sense to spend twenty years training a person and promoting them through the ranks only to discover they were a lunatic or a grifter from the start. Personality flaws have to be detected on day one, before the first entry-level job. The consequence is that the pipeline is narrow. If there aren't enough people with the right temperament, the answer is a smaller civil service, and only a small fraction of it will ever be eligible for promotion to the top.
Leadership college and the encyclopedists
Most of governance is already known. We know from economics that rent control backfires, that regulations raise prices, and that legal codes bloat. We know you can ration by price, by queue, or by procedural complexity, and that you can't escape rationing altogether. We know how tariffs work. Economics, social psychology, and marketing cover a great deal, and what they miss is covered by evolutionary psychology and behavioral genetics. The knowledge isn't missing. It's scattered across a dozen fields, and the leader has to understand all of them.
So it all gets condensed into a leadership curriculum: a single three-year bachelor's degree containing everything we know about governing well. Every civil servant attends leadership college, because every one of them has to be potentially eligible for promotion to the top. In parallel, each earns a second three-year degree in the subject of their department, such as urban planning, forestry, water quality, chemistry, structural or traffic engineering, farm policy, or mental health policy. Every job in the government has a matching degree path taught at the city-state's national college.
At the top of the hierarchy sit the encyclopedists. They maintain an encyclopedia of everything governments have ever tried, recording whether each attempt succeeded or failed according to the values in the national ideology. Much of what the national college teaches is simply that encyclopedia. It is the problem-solutions cycle written down, so that nobody has to rediscover the side effects by suffering them.
The machinery
The executive branch has five parts: a governing council, a chairman who also chairs the council, a council of encyclopedists, the civil service, and the national college. It is, in a sense, a civil service monarchy, with some significant differences at the top.
The council elects the chairman. He can be removed for madness or incompetence, and there are no regular elections. The chairman appoints new members of the council and of the encyclopedists, and he writes the national ideology, always with the advice and consent of the council. Refusing advice, intimidating the council, and making mass firings and appointments are all treated as prima facie evidence of an unstable personality and are grounds for removal. Norms govern the behavior of this government more than any text does. The constitution is, in essence, a set of educated norms, which the encyclopedists maintain and teach to every future politician. Any radical deviation from those norms is itself grounds for removal.
Follow the loop around once. The secret police keep the lists of grifters and lunatics. The recruitment department seeks out people who aren't on them. The national college educates the recruits after hiring. The civil service promotes them. The council picks a chairman from among them, and the chairman appoints the council's replacements and the encyclopedists, and gives guidance on the ideology. The encyclopedists write the encyclopedia according to his normative judgments. Everyone in the loop has a reason to keep the others honest, and everyone is watched by someone below and someone above.
The terms of service are strict. Government employees and council members may do nothing but government. No outside investments, no side businesses. Pay is rich enough to make up for what that costs. Whoever leaves the government cannot come back, and no one can leave without permission, because the civil service is an enlistment with minimum terms, and the training is too expensive to waste. Mental health is monitored for every employee. A civil servant who is found to be mentally ill, or who becomes mentally ill, is gently transferred to a job in the private sector. Nobody is punished for it. They are simply no longer given the keys.
Finally, the system runs on iteration, or I'd be a hypocrite. It conducts small experiments in governance, watches what happens, and writes the results into the Encyclopedia of Government Success and Failure. That is the only part of this design I'm fully confident about, and it is the part I borrowed from the studio.
Only a prototype
I said this is a prototype, so here are the first cracks I can see. The sorting process is only as good as the people who sort, and the secret police and the exam writers are themselves a power-seeking-adjacent job, so the "don't call us" rule has to apply to them most of all. The national ideology is a single point of failure, and a chairman who writes it controls what counts as a correct answer. Surveillance built for recruitment will be tempted to become surveillance for everything else, which is fine actually but runs the risk of becoming an NKVD. And I have not proven that temperament can be read from a short essay. All of these are testable, which is why the experiments matter more than the org chart. Every part of the system is relentlessly looking for ways to improve itself and every past experiment cataloged in the encyclopedia. In fact the recent college graduates should be expected to have the latest knowledge of exactly how the problems solutions cycle is evolving across the government, since their knowledge encompasses the whole thing while existing civil servants have been operating in their narrow domains for as much as 30 years. For this reason ongoing training is required even for management, and department leaders are given new graduates as part of their advisory working group so they have the latest advice.
Part 3: The Education Method
The great thing about the encyclopedists is that forcing everyone to study the problem solutions cycle is a psychological beat down against the worst and most impulsive tendencies of the human species where politics is concerned. Let us imagine a lunatic that somehow worms their way into a position of power. That person has spent 3 years getting a degree learning about what didn't work. This is a direct assault on the ought-therefore-is fallacy. The lunatic learns that reality disagrees. The chud learns that it's not that simple. The grifter learns they will never make any money outside the civil service as long as they stay inside it. If somehow a lunatic bypasses the filters and gets their foot in the door they still face a psychological wall of realism that beats their madness into submission. And the secret police monitoring doesn't stop once you're in, if anything it ratchets up. So a lunatic is shown the door. Ranting itself is a sign of not being qualified for office.
Even the method of education is hostile to lunatics. Lunatics are attracted to lectures and to becoming the lecturer specifically because then they can rant and subject students to listening to things no one would ever listen to consensually. The ranting Puritan is a cycle of abuse and sadism transmitted through the bully pulpit and classroom. It originated in lefty Protestant churches and migrated into colleges.
The method of education uses a course room style instead of a classroom style. Basically you sit in a cubicle by yourself with your head in a book. There is a "course supervisor" that walks around and when you don't understand something you raise your hand. The course supervisor comes over and has you look up any words you don't understand in a dictionary and gives you brief explanations. There are no opportunities for an educator to rant or bully a student. There is no going off topic. There's no opportunity for the educator to inject their own personal opinion, bias, or politics. Education is like a process of copying a copy. If you run a copy through a copy machine you get a degraded copy. If you then run that through the copy machine you get an even more degraded copy. When educators are allowed to inject their own personal politics they corrupt the education process. The next generation of educators then receives that corrupted education. They then inject their personal politics into the process. As this happens the actual education deviates more and more from fidelity to the original plan. The goal is to put the encyclopedia in the brain of every civil servant, not to cultivate a class of ranting lunatic teachers who teach their own personal opinions as holy writ. Doing that would directly contradict the mandate of the council of encyclopedists. We want no deviation from the source of factual data. We also want to neutralize the human tendency for outrage. Students have engaged in sit-ins, protests, and other manipulative games to avoid receiving correct knowledge. Things like human biological diversity are terribly politically incorrect and not suitable for group discussion.
The course room style of education is directly borrowed from Scientology, and was designed by L Ron Hubbard to "neutralize the reactive mind" that resists factual data and "alter-is-es" (corrupts the fidelity of) received data. Basically Hubbard believed that humans compulsively change information they receive and corrupt it. He believed there was something called the reactive mind, which one might define as the subconscious + its knee jerk tendencies. All of Scientology is hostile to the Puritan because all of Scientology is designed to neutralize the psychotic ranter / SP (suppressive person). Scientology conceptualizes itself as a project to make the world more rational. Obviously it has failed to make itself all that rational, but its classroom method has been wildly successful at imparting ideas to people that would otherwise get argued if it was presented in a group. There will be a place within the civil service for group discussion and feedback, but I am removing that feature from the classroom because of how easily it gets hijacked by activists. The appropriate place where people will talk about state ideology will be in small group meetings in their own work unit. Feedback goes up the hierarchy, orders go down. Feedback is not allowed to turn into mass protest, and certainly not mass resistance within the civil service itself. A student who demonstrates is a student who gets expelled or jailed.
And yes. I am borrowing a highly successful method of neutralizing leftist lunacy from a cult. Deal with it. If it works it works. The course room style method isolates the student and forces them to read the book. In Scientology this is because the cult wants to prevent people from detecting inconsistencies, which would happen in a group setting with a lecturer teaching a class. So they have you sit in a cubicle and study a book, and have the course supervisor come around and answer your questions. But we are not trying to neutralize students noticing ideological inconsistencies.
For our purposes it's fine for them to notice whatever they want because the government is not built on moral consistency (and the idea that it should be morally consistent is a lunatic concept). It is built on what worked in the past. It is built on a cycle of experimentation, observation, and then writing down what worked. It is built the same way a garden is built. You notice that too much fertilizer burns the plants so you develop a protocol to use just the right amount and not too much. You observe that flooding the fields causes salts to build up so you use drip irrigation. You observe that diatomaceous earth kills the pests so you spread it around the base of your plants. You observe that these plants require dappled shade so you plant them in shade but those require full sun so you plant them in sun.
If too much welfare grows too many degenerates you use less fertilizer. If too many regulations stop small business creation you prune your grape vines less. If too many commies are infesting your pumpkin patch you spray insecticide. In the garden nothing is about morality and everything is about inputs and outcomes. Closely observing results is how you find out what you need to be doing.
Government is not a process of moral consistency any more than gardening is about moral consistency. Government is a garden or a farm or even a medical practice. It follows an observation, iteration, improvement loop. The encyclopedia is the medical textbook of the government. The system is continuously seeking to add knowledge to the encyclopedia and avoid making past mistakes. Before the system does anything it wants to consult what happened in the past. This has nothing to do with holier than thou "moral consistency" and saying that moral consistency matters in politics is as deranged as saying that moral consistency matters in fertilizer dosing.
There is a separate department that does nothing but survey the public continuously to find out how the government is performing, allow people to submit their complaints, and use all that data to detect corruption and mismanagement. The state will have an entire quality control department dedicated to finding its own malfeasance. But we're not allowing CIA sponsored color revolutions to push us around. People's rights matter in sense that caring about what works also involves caring about whether a population is disgruntled. A government should not have to oppress its population to function. The city state should be such a nice place to live that its high quality of life is its own justification. Its moral justification for its existence comes from the fact that nobody wants to exit and everyone wants to enter. Its political formula is its competence; it gets its legitimacy from superior competence at everything, and that includes upholding rights. It follows the rule of law, but the executive is not bound by the rule of law, because how can an executive bind itself? Especially when that executive has such unilateral power to change law? The council votes on whether to adopt laws that the executive recommends. But the executive appoints the council, can fire them, and so this is mostly a procedural check rather than an actual one. The purpose of the council is basically to force whoever's in charge to hear feedback. Rash decisions are the enemy of good governance and executives work in groups up and down the hierarchy, where there is a boss with final decision but he is required to listen to others advice before making a decision. They are all experts. They have all gone to the same educational process. They all hold double degrees in both a specialty and general understanding of governance. Every single one of them has a Baccalaureate Encyclopedia. They are taught to BE experts, to listen to experts in other fields, and to know when other experts are lying or bloviating beyond their specialty. They understand the problem-solutions cycle. They know all the problems they solve are caused by previous administrations who implemented solutions. They are cautious by nature.
What about the participation of the public in the government?
What about it lol. The public has no participation. We have a complaints department.
Part 4: Sources of Legitimacy
You have the right to equal justice under law. This is taken very seriously and the complaints department will ruthlessly investigate any official abusing their position or doing anything to you that they're not required to do to everyone. Moldbug advocates against an administrative state, favoring instead raw executive power. I completely disagree. The city state is nothing if not completely procedural. It runs on nothing but procedure. It differs from an American civil service in the sense that there are points in the hierarchy where discretion is possible, but those points are leaders and their advisory groups that have the power to change policy, not random officials making decisions with their own judgment. There is always a procedure, and when there isn't, feedback is run up the hierarchy to the appropriate leader who then sends an order back down. Decisions are documented, and their results added to the encyclopedia for further study. Everything is meticulous.
Courts of grievance
If you don't like what the government has done and complaining isn't enough for you you can file suit in a grievance court. Like everything in this system it works more on norms and less on constitutional procedures. The whole system has the flavor of highly developed norms doing the load bearing work that excessive constitutional proceduralism normally does in a democracy. This is because I don't like being bound by arbitrary rules.
There is a jury composed of ordinary citizens randomly selected from the population. But the verdict of this jury is not final and merely advisory. You explain how the government has wronged you, the adjudicator listens very carefully, and then the jury decides if they find the complaint morally valid. They're not being asked if government's actions violated the law. They are instead being asked if the population is against what the government did. This happens behind closed doors and is further information for the encyclopedia. When you feel the government has wronged you the government wants you to file suit in a grievance court. We're going to bring in a big jury of something like 25 people and ask them if they think what the government did was wrong. Their verdict is more like a poll than a verdict and does not have to be unanimous. We will probably pay you some restitution if the jury overwhelmingly takes your side. Every suit that happens is telling us that the population resists a policy, that the policy is creating friction and not widely supported by the public. If the policy encounters too much friction we may cancel it simply to reduce public resistance. The purpose of the grievance court is to tell us when our actions have gone too far. Even if a policy is successful on technical grounds it may be canceled on the grounds of too much public resistance. These proceedings are of course private and no one involved may speak of it. There are lots of these grievance suits being heard all the time. Policies get canceled and adjusted to reduce friction. Procedural checks get added to prevent abuse by officials. More feedback added to the encyclopedia.
Legitimacy and the formal poll
There are two kinds of polls, the one they do by phone when they call you and ask you a hundred questions, and the one that looks remarkably similar to voting. The system doesn't believe in the public voting, but it does believe in doing something that looks remarkably similar to voting, that smells like voting, and is mostly binding.
When the government wants to do something especially something that might be controversial, it propagandizes the entire population. It spends a few months or years drumming up support for a concept. It runs phone polls continuously to see if the public is willing to support it. If the concept seems to take in the public imagination then the government does a formal poll. This is where people are brought off the street and brought into a voting center. There are voting booths, ballot counting machines, and all the trappings of democracy. Why would anyone bother with this? Because it's a psychological operation and not only do we obey the outcome of the poll, we obey the outcome even when it contradicts our desire. You see it, just to prove to the public that we care, occasionally we take some issue we don't really care that much about, then we try to propagandize the public into supporting one particular position knowing full well they probably won't. In fact we let the public openly disagree a lot more than usual. We hold the formal poll knowing full well that the proposal will fail and we will get egg on our faces. We embarrass ourselves deliberately about some small thing that we don't really care about and won't really cost us legitimacy. We want to show that we kind of will actually obey the will of the people. But we tell people this is a poll and not a vote and we reserve the right to do whatever the fuck we want. The system wants to establish the following norms:
Your disagreement matters and will be taken seriously
Policies that do not have overwhelming support will be polled
We will obey the results of the poll
We reserve the right not to obey the results of the poll
We want the norm to be stronger than the legal right, if that makes any sense? We want the expectation to exist that leaders take polls, that polling the public is taken seriously, that the grievances of the public matter, that laws will be modified or relaxed if the public pushes back too much. This is both sincere and cynical. It's a cynical play because it's a psychological observation. It's sincere because we actually will change things if there is resistance. It's sincere because we actually do care about good governance. And it's institutionalized as a norm in order to force future administrations to do it too.
The formal poll is a regime legitimacy tool. Its purpose is to find out how we are doing. The poll isn't just a vote. You can sit down and write out an entire essay about how this official sucks or that official is a jerk and so forth. That data might even make its way into his personnel folder and affect his eligibility for promotion. And if it touches on a it is yet more data for the encyclopedia.
Part 5: Harvesting Loosh from Fanatics
Every successful system depends on redirecting anti-social energy into prosocial behaviors. As a joke I'm calling that "loosh harvesting."
Excluding the fanatics from the government runs into the problem that they may organize themselves outside of our surveillance. We want to keep them on a farm and make them productive, and we can use their obsession to fuel our process of knowledge discovery. We need a tool that simultaneously lets us surveil them while using their energy. This is a great plan for a special kind of social network.
The usual design is really bad at this. Social media is the biggest feedback channel ever built, and it is optimized to produce the loudest reaction rather than the most accurate observation. A like measures how many people nodded, which is the one thing nobody needed to know. The existing platforms are, more or less, machines for converting chuds into lunatics and renting out the lunatics to grifters.
Design for the most functional and competent government has a hole in it. A government built on selection and education knows a great deal about how things work, but it still needs to hear from the people who live under it. The people see the side effects first without understanding the logic that created them. A traffic engineer can model the stop sign. The woman who lives on the next street learns about the rerouted traffic when it wakes her kid up. Feedback is extremely valuable but you're running the risk of encouraging too much participation in government. When you solicit so much feedback and create a responsive state you run the risk of creating an extreme level of entitlement. You want to get your feedback without creating entitlement or importing the lunatic and grifter through the front door.
So the city-state builds its own instrument, and the instrument is a social network organized around cause and effect.
Moldbug once had this concept called the antiversity, basically the opposite of the Cathedral. A perfect antiversity is a kind of truth telling engine. It turns out that uncensored social media tends to just gravitate towards pure truth over time. But noticing is not the same as drilling down to understand the nitty gritty reasons behind government policies. When a person has a grievance we want them to understand exactly why the state did what it did and why it could be no other way. This is a much more fine-grained version of the truth. In order to accomplish this goal social media itself is turned into an educational tool for training the public in cause and effect.
Most people can think one step ahead. People struggle to understand secondary consequences. Even fewer can understand tertiary consequences. Every policy has a consequence, every consequence has a consequence and so on and so forth. Our city state responds to this by forcing every single social media site to incorporate problem solutions chain maps into its design.
Part 6: Social Media And The Chain Map
The basic unit is a claim about the world. It might be an event or a standing condition: a rule passed in a certain year, rents in a certain neighborhood over a certain period, a bus route cut. The important object is not the claim but the link between claims. A link says that one thing contributed to another, and it carries a record. It states the mechanism, the type of relationship (necessary, sufficient, contributing, enabling, preventing), a rough size, how long the effect took, and what evidence supports it. People argue, cite, and revise at the link, because that is where real disagreements live. Almost nobody disputes that rents rose. They dispute why.
You want to make air travel safe. So you regulated to make the planes as safe as possible. That raises the price of air fare. People respond by driving more. Because driving is so much more lethal than flying your regulation has the paradoxical effect of increasing the number of deaths.
You impose rent control. The result is the decay of the housing stock, hostile relationship between owners and their tenants, and no new builds.
You had a bunch of regulations that add a year of regulatory bloat to the process of building anything. The developer has to pay 7 architects for two years of salary at $50,000 each because of two years of regulatory drag. A business cannot survive without making money and so it is forced to pass on these costs in the form of higher prices. The result is that the new condominiums cost an extra $200,000 each. The insane activist lunatics protest the high cost of housing without ever realizing that they are the reason for the high cost, but it was activists like them who created all the regulations that raised the cost.
The point is, the government is filled with crap like this. Generally when there's a problem with the market it is the government's fault and when there is a problem with the government it is the market's fault. One brides the other, the other creates market failure for the one. The activists screech and make it worse. You want the whole society to see the chain of cause and effect. You want to artificially inflate the IQ of the average human by making them think four or five steps ahead and backwards about every single problem society faces. When the process is complete and they may not like the government's policies, they might have gone a different way, but they will understand exactly why the government did it, and why the government isn't the bad guy.
Free social media app is required to have cause and effect maps built into it. When somebody types words into their tweet the AI identifies every social problem and then generates a link. The tweet winds up with these highlighted words and when you click on those words it puts you into the cause of that particular problem. You follow these links down the causal chain and get to see the problem solution cycle in real time. Every social media app is thus also a problem-solutions-cycle app which forces the user to think in terms of primary, secondary, and tertiary consequences. The psychological beatdown doesn't just affect the lunatics. It affects the whole population by showing everyone there are no simple answers.
When you tweet that the government should "do something about a problem" the equivalent of an aggressive community notes system will show all the trade offs and all the possible solutions that have been considered. In essence every social media app is an extension of The Encyclopedia.
Three rules keep it honest. A cause has to come before its effect, which kills a whole genre of nonsense and turns feedback loops into sequences over time. A link with no mechanism is allowed, but it is labeled an association and drawn differently, so a correlation can't dress up as a cause. And any link can be broken into smaller steps: "A caused B" becomes "A caused M, and M caused B," with the original kept as a shortcut. That last rule is the iterative method again. The crude first guess goes in, and the map improves as people replace vague links with testable ones.
Endless scrolling and feeds might be banned, but regardless every app must allow you to swipe left or right backwards and forwards through the chain of causality. You enter at a claim and move in two directions: what caused this, and what did this cause. Discovery comes from a view that shows where the map is thin or contested, so attention goes where it is most needed rather than where it is most entertaining. Nothing is ranked by reactions. Reputation attaches to the links you contributed and how they held up when better evidence arrived, and a forecast is just a link into a future claim that gets resolved later. Over time you can see who is reliably right, which is a dull statistic that I find considerably more useful than a follower count. The system uses algorithms to assign accuracy percentages to each account, that is how accurate an account is at determining causality.
This is the problem-solutions cycle drawn as a picture. A policy is a node with one link to the thing it was meant to fix and several links to the things it broke. The second set of links is where most of the arguing happens, and it is exactly the part the chud never sees.
Advocating a policy also triggers links in the form of "this has already been done before and is the predicted consequence of what this person recommends." Incoherent rage without a recommendation gets downranked.
The effect is that the whole population understands why its government is doing what it's doing, and if they don't necessarily agree on the exact color of the stationery. This simultaneously legitimizes the regime and also puts a burden of extreme competence on it. Yes, the whole population is educated enough to second-guess you, no they don't have power, but they all understand why you made the decision you did. The general effect is that the population has moral faith in their government.
The map also feeds the machinery described earlier. The encyclopedists take it as raw input for the Encyclopedia of Government Success and Failure, and the small experiments the government runs produce new evidence that goes back onto the map. It also becomes part of the recruitment pipeline. Someone who consistently contributes accurate links without ever campaigning for anything is exactly the person the state is looking for, and the surveillance system can notice them the same way it notices everyone else. Anyone who uses the map as a platform for seeking power goes on the list. Contribute because you care how things work, and you might get a call. Contribute to get a call, and you won't. And really important predictions might be linked to the prediction markets.
Part 7: The Ultimate Mansplainer
The national AI will explain in excruciating detail why it must be done a certain way and could be done no other way. It will query the national encyclopedia and tell you about all the other ways your suggestion failed. If you have a suggestion it will tell you why your suggestion has been dismissed. It will tell you that has been tried, and failed. And here's why. You can argue with it all day and all night. It's completely free to use. The AI will talk to you non-stop telling you how you are wrong, how the government is right, and how it could be no other way. It will provide statistics and evidence and proof and it is never wrong. If by some miracle you actually have an original thought, an original program, that can actually change things and work better than the status quo, that information will be relayed by the machine to the appropriate authorities. But you won't, because you don't, because we already thought of that. The encyclopedists studied that option and dismissed it for various reasons. Thank you for your feedback. Is there something else you would like to talk about? We can talk about any government policy at all. And the machine will tell you why the government's policy is the right policy and could be no other way.
Part 8: A Spectacle For The Chud
Chuds need beer and monster trucks. Chuds need gladiatorial competitions and death races. The chud is not evil but he thinks there are simple solutions and that's dangerous because there are no solutions, only an endless chain of problems. And we tried that option. Okay, we didn't try it but we thought about it and dismissed it because it's stupid. The chud needs to know this. He needs to be told that his little chud brain can't handle all the big complexities of the world. And then he needs his brain stuffed full of spectacles to distract him, so we will give him oily lesbians mud wrestling on TV, monster truck derbies, death races, and literal gladiatorial fights. Anything to keep his small chud brain preoccupied and away from expert governance. While the educated chud is integral to our plans the uneducated one is a dangerous idealist.
Part 9: The National Ideology
The national ideology is indistinguishable from all our methods. When a civil servant is sent to the government's leadership college the general three year degree they get teaches them subjects whose names revolve around the process that defines them rather than the topic. All classes are interdisciplinary. What unifies them is process that cuts across disciplines. Here are some possible examples of class titles:
Encyclopedia 101: Trade-offs and Side Effects Of Government Policy 1
Covers a new domain of harmful side effects of government policy every week: housing policy, general over regulation, environmental law, forestry, highway policy, etc.
Encyclopedia 110: Trade-offs and Side Effects Of Government Policy 2
Covers a new domain of harmful side effects of government policy every week over 13 weeks: consumer regulation, banking, financial law, nutritional policy, etc.
History 100: History of Material Forces
Discusses the origins of famous historical events in the material forces of each era. Attempts to build a material and technological view of history.
Encyclopedia 301: Successes And Failures In Foreign Policy
Covers the history of successes and failures in foreign policy. Each week foreign policy scenarios are discussed with historical references for their successes and failures. Goal of the class is to impart an ultra realistic view of what has worked in the past for negotiations with foreign leaders, trade deals, and military brinksmanship.
Biology 400: Human Biodiversity
Covers a detailed breakdown of productivity levels, taxation receipts, IQ and crime levels by immigrant population and racial classification. Discusses cybernetic feedback loops for population management, birth rates, and maximizing productive and healthy traits in the population.
Other titles would be pretty self-explanatory:
Econ 120: Introduction to Microeconomics and Trade-offs
Encyclopedia 401: Behavioral Genetics and Evolutionary Psychology 1
Encyclopedia 215: Military Strategy 1
Encyclopedia 220: Military Strategy 2
This represents an ultra based, cause and effect focused and interdisciplinary curriculum focused on giving a person the ability to see causal chains rippling through the entire society. This is like everything else in this system: focused on what worked in the past and what didn't.
Edit: Part 6 (the social media system) might give critics of the system too much power. It is probably better to use social media as a sensor only to collect more feedback about what the public is thinking, and not actually teach the whole population to understand the chain of causality. A population that well informed becomes extremely sharp in its criticism and could pose a threat to regime stability. A social media network that traces chains of causality would work better in a democracy than a monarchy. Better that AI generated links simply point to official government explanations than open the door to criticism.